From :
K.R.Athiyaman,
Chennai
To :
The CPM Politbureau, New Delhi
Dear Sirs,
I am a middle class man working in a private concernin Chennai. I would like to share my views aboutworking class conditions with you.
The unorganised sector constitutes the majority of theworking class : about 91 % ; they are not unionisedand have no security or other benefits.We support privatisation as we feel it will reducecorruptiion, wastage of public funds, and reduce thecost of services and goods ; and increase employement and prosperity in the long run.
In TN, public transport system is to be partiallyprivatised. And naturally your party opposes it onideological grounds. But reality is somethingdiffernt. No one cares for us public who use theinefficent and insufficeint public transport system.If properly liberated from the License Raj (theexisting private bus toutes are sold for lakhs of rupees in black money among the monopoly privateoperators, as you very well know), we belive the bus transport will be efficent and cheap like thelorry transport sector which is efficent and free.We do not have sufficent buses ; and entire publictransport corporations incur losses not because of cross subsidisation or running busues to remote villages. The losses are mainly due to corruption,lack of accountablity, top heavy adminstration andpolitical interferance and nepotism. No one can reformor improve the existing system.If the system is privatised and liberalised like the lorry transport system, then there will be sufficentand cheap buses all over the country.
Yes, there will retrenchment among the govt workers ;they may get jobs with the private bus companies ;the salary may reduce but the buses will be good.May i ask you, why you are bothered only when suchwell paid minority workers loose jobs ; but do notcare when millions of casual labourers (whodesperately need cheap bus transport) loose theirjobs.
Reg bad debts in public sector banks of 75000 crores :Why do only PSU banks have such severe problems ? whyare private banks like LVB, KVB healthy. You do not address the core of the probelm : the corrupt bankemployees who doled out the loans to unethical business men. Blaming the business men alone will notsolve the problem. And the govt of India (means the tax paying public) will have to bear the burden inwriting off these loans. Like UTI fiasco...
The govt of India and the state govts are all bankruptand very soon paying salary for govt employees isgoing to be a struggle.The CPM West Bengal Govt does privatisation and had recently appointed Mackinskey & Co of USA asconsultants for restrutaring process. Can you expain the double standards of CPM in thisregard ??Personnaly i feel that to be a communist, it takesdedication, selfless nature and above all honesty.
The majority of the organsied trade unions (like therailway union members) are dishonest and misuse theirmembership. They do not care for the real prolateriatof India : the unorganised sector, who are exploited,over worked and under paid); that is why the reach ofCPM is shrinking and strikes organised by govt unionsand others get very little attention from the realproletariat. We do not care.
I have yet to meet a honest union leader from INDIAN Railways who has not amassed a fortune by misusing hisposition. Most of these members have bourgeousie mentality and are fascists. Yet you count them as yourcomrades and dream of using them as instruments of revolution.
Swami Vivekanada (a socialistic swami) called for just 100 dedicated and selfless young men to followhim so that he can change the world. The important factor is that he needed honest and selfless youngmen. QUALITY IS VERY IMPORTANT THAN QUANTITY.You may dismiss me as a bourgeousie or a revisionist ;but in our opinion you can never in 10000 yearssucceed in bringing in a revolution like October revolution of 1918, WITH THESE PSEUDO COMRADES.
With Regards
Athiyaman.K.R
Chennai
Showing posts with label Socialism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Socialism. Show all posts
Monday, May 02, 2005
The real cost of Socialism in India
Reg : Socialism
All our problems in Indian socieity can be traced to unpractical socialism / leftist ideas since 1947.The corruption, nepotisim, fall in moral standards andvalues in all spheres of life is directly linked tothe undermining of our national currency.the socilistic govts until 1991, stiffled growth ofprivate sector (explotiting imperialists !!) and further spent huge money (borrowed or printed ortaxed)on huge PSUs and in reckless expansion of govtmacihnery and creating white elephants like SAIL. while the price of all products produced by PSUs werevery high due to lack of competition and inefficiency,there was also acute shortage of goods (like cementuntil 1980). it gave rise to black market, smuggling,horading and bribery among govt officials.
At one time there was a maximum taxation of about 90 % for many corporates (in addition to high powercharges, sales tax and excise) ; naturally it led toevasion of taxes and created black money.moreover the govt created inflation by meeting thebudgetery and other deficits by printing money.if the wage levels doubled in ten years, price levelsmultipied by four times. And interest rates werearound 20 % ( and unofficial and real rate at around30 % or more ) . Micro credit in samll town markets, etc is at 200 % (kandhu vatti).all govt stastics reg inflation, interest rates, etcae half triths and doesn't cover the black moneysegment. corruption grew slowly and steadily, as it wasimpossible to live honestly on a fixed salary whileprices were rising annually. and huge power was centralised and given to bureacrats who ruled in thelicense permit, quota raj. naturally, they too becomecorrupt. and their culture spread form dept to deptand finally reached the armed forces (Tehelka, Bofors,etc).
Indians were not this corrupt and morally degradedin 1947. There was expoitation, feudalism,zamindarism,casteism, poverty, unempolyment and hunger then ;but as a whole moral values were very high, producingexemplery leaders in politics and other related fields.
These modern day leftists rever Lord Keyenes, whoadvocated deficit financing to stimulate growth.but he prescribed only 2% or less defict. not the 12.5 % defict (gross defict of central and state govtsput togehter as a ratio of GDP). this defict is madeup by recklessly printing money.Keyes had said " there is no better way to underminethe moral and political standards of a nation than byunderming her currency. "there are no free lunches in this world. only wealth,which has been created can be redistriubuted to all.
Soviet Union crumbled not because of US capitalsiticconspiracy, or by huge defence expeditures or byexporting revolution to third world countries atenormous cost ; it crumbled mainly because of overcentralisation of power with burecarcy, corrputionand inefficency of the state run PSUs, etc.in short, during the last decades of soviet union,the entire country was run like our present TamilNadu Sate Transport Corporation or Co-op Mills.
The chinese are more wiser and far sighted ; they areliberalising fast and invited MNCs to invest in China.china is still ruled by the Communist party with aniron fist ;they are under no presuure from IMF orWorld Bank or US or WTO ; they sponateously do whatthey are doing. Why don't the Indian communists understand and analyse these factors ?
Please read the book " Free to Choose" by MiltonFreedman,an US free market economist (Nobel prize winner).Competition is most important (while privatising) toensure efficency and productivity. you know very wellthe difference in the bus transport and lorrytransportsector in India. if licences are totally abolishedand free enterprise is allowed in bus transports, then there will be good, sufficeint and cheap buses in all routes ; and moreover the corruption intransport ministry and burecracy, and trade unionswill be finished.
Only 9 % of the total labour force in India comes under organised sector. There is no hope or securityfor the crores of contract labourers, child labourers,agri workers ,etc. if labour laws are liberalisedand hire or fire system is introduced in all sectors(including the govt), the sky will not fall down.the best way that anyone can help the poor in Indiais by stopping the reckless printing of money topay the govt expenses. by guranting the minimum wagesthey get does not erode in real value (purchasingpower), the govt can help them. (than with all theanti-poverty alievation schemes)and the govt is bankrupt ; so we will sell all govtPSUs eventually to meet the deficits.
The dramatic fall in STD rates is a good example offree enterprise Vs govt monopoly. And we are payingartifically high rates for Diesel, Petrol and powerdue to govt monopoloy and corruption.
All our problems in Indian socieity can be traced to unpractical socialism / leftist ideas since 1947.The corruption, nepotisim, fall in moral standards andvalues in all spheres of life is directly linked tothe undermining of our national currency.the socilistic govts until 1991, stiffled growth ofprivate sector (explotiting imperialists !!) and further spent huge money (borrowed or printed ortaxed)on huge PSUs and in reckless expansion of govtmacihnery and creating white elephants like SAIL. while the price of all products produced by PSUs werevery high due to lack of competition and inefficiency,there was also acute shortage of goods (like cementuntil 1980). it gave rise to black market, smuggling,horading and bribery among govt officials.
At one time there was a maximum taxation of about 90 % for many corporates (in addition to high powercharges, sales tax and excise) ; naturally it led toevasion of taxes and created black money.moreover the govt created inflation by meeting thebudgetery and other deficits by printing money.if the wage levels doubled in ten years, price levelsmultipied by four times. And interest rates werearound 20 % ( and unofficial and real rate at around30 % or more ) . Micro credit in samll town markets, etc is at 200 % (kandhu vatti).all govt stastics reg inflation, interest rates, etcae half triths and doesn't cover the black moneysegment. corruption grew slowly and steadily, as it wasimpossible to live honestly on a fixed salary whileprices were rising annually. and huge power was centralised and given to bureacrats who ruled in thelicense permit, quota raj. naturally, they too becomecorrupt. and their culture spread form dept to deptand finally reached the armed forces (Tehelka, Bofors,etc).
Indians were not this corrupt and morally degradedin 1947. There was expoitation, feudalism,zamindarism,casteism, poverty, unempolyment and hunger then ;but as a whole moral values were very high, producingexemplery leaders in politics and other related fields.
These modern day leftists rever Lord Keyenes, whoadvocated deficit financing to stimulate growth.but he prescribed only 2% or less defict. not the 12.5 % defict (gross defict of central and state govtsput togehter as a ratio of GDP). this defict is madeup by recklessly printing money.Keyes had said " there is no better way to underminethe moral and political standards of a nation than byunderming her currency. "there are no free lunches in this world. only wealth,which has been created can be redistriubuted to all.
Soviet Union crumbled not because of US capitalsiticconspiracy, or by huge defence expeditures or byexporting revolution to third world countries atenormous cost ; it crumbled mainly because of overcentralisation of power with burecarcy, corrputionand inefficency of the state run PSUs, etc.in short, during the last decades of soviet union,the entire country was run like our present TamilNadu Sate Transport Corporation or Co-op Mills.
The chinese are more wiser and far sighted ; they areliberalising fast and invited MNCs to invest in China.china is still ruled by the Communist party with aniron fist ;they are under no presuure from IMF orWorld Bank or US or WTO ; they sponateously do whatthey are doing. Why don't the Indian communists understand and analyse these factors ?
Please read the book " Free to Choose" by MiltonFreedman,an US free market economist (Nobel prize winner).Competition is most important (while privatising) toensure efficency and productivity. you know very wellthe difference in the bus transport and lorrytransportsector in India. if licences are totally abolishedand free enterprise is allowed in bus transports, then there will be good, sufficeint and cheap buses in all routes ; and moreover the corruption intransport ministry and burecracy, and trade unionswill be finished.
Only 9 % of the total labour force in India comes under organised sector. There is no hope or securityfor the crores of contract labourers, child labourers,agri workers ,etc. if labour laws are liberalisedand hire or fire system is introduced in all sectors(including the govt), the sky will not fall down.the best way that anyone can help the poor in Indiais by stopping the reckless printing of money topay the govt expenses. by guranting the minimum wagesthey get does not erode in real value (purchasingpower), the govt can help them. (than with all theanti-poverty alievation schemes)and the govt is bankrupt ; so we will sell all govtPSUs eventually to meet the deficits.
The dramatic fall in STD rates is a good example offree enterprise Vs govt monopoly. And we are payingartifically high rates for Diesel, Petrol and powerdue to govt monopoloy and corruption.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
